Compliance

Form I-9 and E-Verify: Onboarding Compliance Tips for Employers

Written by

OnBlick Inc

Updated On

January 15, 2025

Header image

Onboarding is a crucial aspect of the hiring process as it ensures the integration of new hires into the organization as per the legal and regulatory requirements. Employers must follow guidelines that ensure compliance with labor laws, workplace safety standards, and anti-discrimination regulations. 

Non-compliance can cause serious reputational damage to the organization, negatively affecting the employees. Employers can ensure a smooth transition for new hires by following a standardized, legally sound process onboarding process. 

In this blog, we will talk about the key aspects of onboarding compliance and how employers can adapt to these practices easily.  

Why is a Pleasant Onboarding Experience Important?  

A positive onboarding experience helps new hires better understand their organization’s culture and align their individual goals with the business’s long-term objectives.  

During onboarding, employers acclimatize new hires into their respective departments by completing necessary formalities and providing essential resources and training to help them understand their responsibilities effectively.  

A productive onboarding experience:

  • Enhances Employee Engagement: Employees who feel appreciated and welcomed on their first day are motivated to work with dedication and are more likely to stay engaged for longer periods. 
  • Boosts Retention: A positive onboarding experience is crucial for leaving a lasting impression on employees, increasing the likelihood of long-term retention and job satisfaction. 
  • Increases Productivity: When employers guide new hires on their first day and help them with the company’s policies, they feel confident and valued, which motivates them to work more efficiently and deliver the best results. 
  • Fosters a productive work environment: A well-structured onboarding helps new hires connect with the company’s values and missions, encouraging them to align their individual goals with the organization’s long-term vision.  

 Onboarding Compliance: Why Does it Matter? 

Employees are entitled to a workplace that meets their needs and protects their rights. To ensure fair work practices and create a safe working environment for the employees, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) and Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) set some rules to inform employees about their rights and ensure their legal requirements are met, eliminating the risk of lawsuits and fines.  

Key reasons to maintain onboarding compliance include:

  • Legal Protection: Ensures the organization adheres to labor laws, tax regulations, and workplace safety standards. 
  • Employee Safety and Rights: Makes sure employees’ safety is not compromised, and they are aware of their rights, safety protocols, and company policies. 
  • Risk Mitigation: Reduces the risk of legal lawsuits and penalties, workplace accidents, or issues that can significantly impact the company’s image in the industry.  
  • Smooth Integration: Allows employees to quickly adapt to the company’s culture and comply with the essential training sessions designed to familiarize them with their roles and policies.  

Importance of Form I-9 Compliance

The Form I-9, or the Employment Eligibility Verification form, is a crucial component of the hiring process in the United States. It verifies an employee’s identity and authorization to work in the United States and ensures that they comply with U.S. immigration laws.  

Form I-9 is filled out by both the employee and the employer. Section 1 of the form must be filled out by the employee on or before their first day of employment, and the employer must fill out Section 2 within three business days of the employee’s joining date.  

Compliance with Form I-9 is crucial because:  

  • Legal Obligation: Completing Form I-9 is a federal requirement mandated by the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) 1986. Employers who fail to submit this form promptly can face serious legal and financial penalties.  
  • Risks of Audits: To ensure transparency and compliance, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) conducts regular audits, and non-compliance or any errors can lead to legal consequences. 
  • Accurate Record-Keeping: To promote ethical hiring practices in the workplace and prevent fraud, employers must retain I-9 Forms for at least three years after employment ends. 

Why is E-Verify Compliance Significant?

E-Verify is an online system operated by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). It compares information from an employee’s Form I-9 to records in the government databases to confirm employment eligibility by evaluating whether the employee is authorized to work in the United States. This program is only mandatory for Federal Contractors, Subcontractors, and State and Local Government Mandates.  

Key Reasons for E-Verify Compliance are:

  • Enhanced Verification: E-Verify adds an extra layer of security and guarantees the safety of all employee documents, helping employers avoid hiring individuals with suspicious or fraudulent backgrounds.  
  • Reduced Legal Risks: Employers who fail to comply with the onboarding guidelines risk facing legal lawsuits and costly fines. Non-compliance also damages the employer’s reputation, negatively affecting the organization’s work culture. 
  • Efficient Processing: E-Verify eliminates the manual methods of reviewing and verifying documents and allows employers to assess these documents online easily, reducing the risks of delays or misplacing important documentation. 

Onboarding Compliance: 6 Tips for Employers 

Maintaining onboarding compliance is essential to facilitate a lawful employment process and employee retention. It helps create a productive work environment and makes employees feel safe and comfortable.  

Employers can maintain compliance by adhering to a set of established guidelines or regulations, such as: 

  1. Develop Clear Policies: Establish detailed guidelines for completing and managing Form I-9, E-Verify submissions, and immigration-related processes to reduce errors and confusion.
  1. Manage Form I-9 and E-Verify: Ensure Forms I-9 are accurately completed within the required timeframe, and E-Verify cases are submitted promptly to avoid compliance breaches.
  1. Train HR Teams: Provide regular training for HR teams on the latest Form I-9 and E-Verify requirements, ensuring they are equipped to avoid common errors and handle compliance confidently.
  1. Conduct Internal Audits: Perform routine internal audits of I-9 records and E-Verify submissions to identify and address potential compliance issues before external reviews.
  1. Standardize Your Processes: Use standardized forms and procedures for completing I-9 and E-Verify tasks, ensuring consistency across locations and departments for smooth compliance management.

  2. Leverage Technology: Invest in efficient compliance software to automate I-9 completion, E-Verify submissions, and documentation storage, reducing manual errors and administrative overhead.

How OnBlick Simplifies Onboarding Compliance

Onboarding compliance does not have to be daunting; following a structured approach can simplify it. OnBlick offers an integrated solution to help employers easily fulfill I-9 and E-Verify requirements.  

Here’s how OnBlick adds value to your business: 

  • Automated Form I-9 Completion: OnBlick ensures accurate and efficient completion of your Form I-9, minimizing errors that can lead to non-compliance. 
  • Seamless E-Verify Integration: OnBlick directly integrates with the E-Verify system, saving time and reducing the risks of compliance-related issues.  
  • Compliance Alerts: With the help of automated notifications for Form I-9, document re-verification, and upcoming expirations, OnBlick reduces the likelihood of your business missing any important deadline.
  • Secure Record Management: OnBlick ensures all important employee records are securely saved and easily accessed, allowing businesses to maintain sensitive information without any hassle.  
  • Policy Standardization and Training: By providing specific customizable templates and automated workflows, OnBlick helps businesses standardize onboarding policies across the company.  
  • I-9 Internal Audit Services: OnBlick’s I-9 audit assistance ensures your organization is audit-ready by providing regulatory updates, process support, internal audit guidance, policy creation, onboarding best practices, and remote hire solutions.
  • E-Verify Desk Review Services: OnBlick automates submissions for accuracy and timeliness, provides expert guidance, and assures comprehensive audit preparation to keep you desk review-ready with ease.

The software also offers training modules confirming that all new hires receive consistent training regarding company policies and procedures. 

Final Thoughts

Creating a delightful onboarding experience is important for both employers and employees. It allows the new hires to adapt to their new surroundings and align their goals with the long-term business requirements. To maintain fair practices and foster a transparent working environment, employers must follow guidelines that will help them stay compliant and avoid penalties.   

Onboarding compliance is essential as it informs the new hires about their legal rights and ensures that the employer provides all the necessary resources. To ensure a structured onboarding, employers must accurately fill out Form I-9 and manage E-Verify processes.  To reduce the risks of delays and avoid legal lawsuits, employers must conduct regular audits, train HR leaders, promote standardized processes, and leverage technology.  

OnBlick streamlines the onboarding process by automating compliance checks and ensuring all your vital documentation is up-to-date and securely saved. With our compliance reminders, businesses never miss any deadline, thus reducing the risks of penalties and lawsuits. 

Onboard with confidence, book your free demo today! 

Complete, Update and Retain Your Form I-9s Digitally

Learn More